Author(s):
Bodin R*, Robidel F, Rodrigues S, Lecomte A, Villegier AS.
* INERIS, MIV/TEAM, F-60550 Verneuil-en-Halatte.
France
Published in:
Appl Sci 2024; 14 (16): 6978
Published: 09.08.2024
on EMF:data since 05.02.2025
Further publications: Study funded by:

The French Ministry of Ecology Program 190.

Keywords for this study:
Effects on young animals  |  Growth
Medical/biological studies
Go to EMF:data assessment

Delayed Growth in Immature Male Rats Exposed to 900 MHz Radiofrequency.

Original Abstract

People have been exposed to the 900 MHz mobile phone electromagnetic field for approximately 30 years. There is still no conclusion from immature rodent experiments regarding the potential effects of nonthermal radiofrequency (RF) 900 MHz continuous wave exposure during biological development. Here, we test the hypothesis that mother rats exposed at a whole-body specific absorption rate (wbSAR) occupational (Oc) limit of the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection for humans (0.4 W/kg) will show impairments in development, with less effect at the public (Pu) limit (0.08 W/kg). The wbSAR was estimated at 0.4 W/kg to mimic working mothers (OcM exposure) and 0.08 W/kg for non-working mothers, i.e., public (PuM exposure). This pre- and postnatal study is the first to compare public and occupational exposure limits on rat pup physical development. Litter endpoints and the descendants’ body weights and lengths were recorded regularly from birth concomitantly with the age of developmental landmarks. Male neonates showed earlier pinna ear detachment and earlier eye opening in both the OcM and PuM groups, but earlier incisor eruption only in the PuM group. The OcM-exposed males showed lower body weight as juveniles until adolescence. The OcM- and PuM-exposed descendant females showed earlier pinna ear detachment and eye opening with similar body weight. These data suggest variations in the development time of descendant rats when the mother rats received daily 900 MHz continuous waves at human limits for workers and non-workers (public).

Keywords

2G communications | radiofrequency fields | weight | eye opening | ear detachment |
electromagnetic radiation | development

Exposure:

900 MHz
GPRS, Edge (E)/2G
SAR = 0,4; 0,08 W/kg

EMF:data assessment

Summary

The second generation of mobile communications (2G) was introduced in the 1990s with the GSM network (900 MHz). To date, exposure to 900 MHz mobile phone radiation is ubiquitous in both public and occupational settings. The 2G network has been shown to remain the primary source of brain penetration by radiofrequency electromagnetic fields during phone calls. The exposure limits are set at 0.08 W/kg for the general public (Pu) and 0.4 W/kg for occupational exposure (Oc). In both cases, there are particularly vulnerable groups, such as pregnant women, immature individuals (fetuses, newborns, children), and sick or elderly people. It is known that the skulls of fetuses and newborns provide less protection against the penetration of radiofrequency radiation than those of adults. Therefore, it can be assumed that the physiological and developmental protection provided by ICNIRP limits is less effective in vulnerable populations. This study aims to investigate how radiation exposure at public and occupational limits affects growth and development and to what extent these effects differ, using a rat model.

Source: ElektrosmogReport | Issue 1/2025

Study design and methods

A total of 25 pregnant rats were divided into three groups: sham-exposed (n = 9), PuM (n = 8; whole-body SAR 0.08 W/kg), and OcM (n = 8; whole-body SAR 0.4 W/kg). The animals and their offspring were exposed to 900 MHz radiation from day 8 post-fertilization (prenatal) until day 17 after birth (postnatal) between 11:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m. The field strengths were 30.2 V/m (PuM) and 67.5 V/m (OcM). At birth, the litters were reduced to three male and three female pups per litter. One pup of each sex was sacrificed on days 8, 17, and 43 after birth. General litter parameters (litter size, sex ratio, and number of stillbirths) were first analyzed. In addition, pup weight and size were documented from birth until day 43 postpartum. Each pup was examined daily to determine the timing of eye opening, incisor eruption, and ear unfolding. These events are considered developmental markers.

Results

The study found no evidence of adverse effects of perinatal radiation exposure on general litter parameters (litter size, sex ratio, number of stillbirths) or on pup weight and size at birth. However, a statistically significant reduction in body weight was observed in OcM-exposed male pups (0.4 W/kg) from day 6, which persisted until the end of the experiment (day 43). Male pups in both exposed groups were also smaller, although this result did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.0557). However, the effects of 900 MHz exposure on early developmental markers were statistically significant. Eye opening and ear unfolding were observed earlier in both exposure groups and both sexes. Incisor eruption was significantly earlier only in the male pups of the PuM group.

Conclusions

This publication is the first to compare the effects of public and occupational exposure limits on the physical development of rats. The results suggest physical developmental defects (premature ear unfolding, early eye opening, reduced body weight), with occupational exposure limits causing a more pronounced phenotype. The observed phenotype may indicate a metabolic disorder with increased energy demand. The authors note that comparable developmental defects have been observed in newborn rats and mice with chemically disrupted serotonin and dopamine metabolism (Abu-Taweel, 2019; Cai et al., 2023). The neurotoxic effects of these chemicals are partly due to oxidative stress (Huang et al., 2008). (RH)

References:

Abu-Taweel GM (2019): Neurobehavioral protective properties of curcumin against the mercury chloride treated mice offspring. Saudi Journal of Biological Sciences, 26(4), 736-743. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.SJBS.2018.10.016

Cai H, Chen M, Gao Y, Ruan J, He C, Zuo Z (2023): Transgenerational Effects and Mechanisms of Tributyltin Exposure on Neurodevelopment in the Male Offspring of Rats. Environmental Science & Technology, 57(28), 10201-10210. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.3c01546

Huang CF, Hsu CJ, Liu SH, Lin-Shiau SY (2008): Neurotoxicological mechanism of methylmercury induced by low-dose and long-term exposure in mice: Oxidative stress and down-regulated Na+/K+-ATPase involved. Toxicology Letters, 176(3), 188-197. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.TOXLET.2007.11.004

"Premature eye opening and ear unfolding occurred at both field strengths and in both sexes."